A new report from urban thinktank Create Streets has called for councils to prioritise inexpensive street improvements over expensive regeneration schemes, arguing that reducing traffic, removing unnecessary street furniture and creating more welcoming public spaces could increase footfall and spending in struggling UK town centres.
The study, produced jointly with cycle storage company Cyclehoop, argues that high streets have been designed increasingly around motor traffic rather than encouraging people to spend time there. It identifies four stages of decline: the movement of retail to out-of-town shopping centres, the growth of online shopping, the prioritisation of road infrastructure over public spaces and a funding system that favours large regeneration projects.
The report estimates that one parking space in a typical market town generates just over £73,000 in annual spending at nearby shops, based on use by around 3.5 vehicles a day. Using the same 12 square metres for nine shared electric bikes could generate 13 trips daily and more than £146,000 in annual spending. In busier city centres, this figure could exceed £300,000, while repurposing the space for outdoor dining could generate around £120,000 in additional annual spending.
It argues that pedestrian-friendly environments encourage more frequent visits and longer dwell times, while making high streets more attractive to families. The authors recommend introducing a family-friendliness test for publicly funded schemes, based on whether an environment is accessible to everyone from nine-year-olds to people aged 90.
The report highlights several examples of successful interventions. In Altrincham, retail vacancies fell from almost one in three units in 2010 to 7.3 per cent in 2018, while annual footfall increased by more than one million visitors. Stockport's £7 million investment in pedestrianising its historic Underbanks and Market Place contributed to a doubling of reported local footfall over five years.
Smaller projects are presented as equally important. In Grimsby's East Marsh, a disused 150-square-metre site was transformed into a community park for £19,350, incorporating trees, benches, paths and planting. In Salford, Bloom Street was redesigned in 2017 for £40,000, with seating, greenery and cycling infrastructure replacing a layout dominated by parking.
However, the report identifies funding and administrative processes as significant obstacles. Citing Local Government Association figures, it says competitive funding applications can cost councils around £30,000 in staff time, potentially making the application process more expensive than smaller projects themselves. It recommends dedicated funding for schemes costing less than £250,000 and simpler approval processes.
David Milner of Create Streets said: "What works is cheap: trees in the ground, benches people want to sit on, clutter taken away."
The report's foreword author, Lord Gascoigne, chair of the House of Lords Built Environment Committee, said: "Councils should be spending their time getting things done, not filling in forms."
The proposals come as the government pursues a £210 million high street regeneration fund announced in September, with much of the funding intended to support building conversions, community facilities and struggling pubs and clubs.
A spokesperson for the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government told the Guardian that local leaders could use available funding for pedestrianisation and high street regeneration according to their communities' needs.









Recent Stories